Kent Council Scorecard
Methodology
Principles
- Transparent. Every score links to its data source and the date measured.
- Independent. KLN funds and produces the scorecard. No council, regulator, or sponsor edits it.
- Reproducible. Anyone with the same data could produce the same score.
- Disaggregated. We publish each metric separately. We do NOT roll them into a single "best/worst" ranking — that would mislead.
- Refreshed quarterly. The fast-moving metrics (FOI response, refuse complaints) get fresh numbers every quarter; the slower ones (financial health) annually. The October 2026 refresh was published on 2 November 2026; next refresh expected January 2027.
- Politically attributed. Every score names the administration in office during the data period — not necessarily the administration in office today. See "Political attribution" below.
- Right of reply. Councils receive an itemised notice of every new or changed score at least 14 working days before publication, to flag factual errors or missing context.
Banding scale
Each metric is scored 0-100 and banded:
| Band | Score range | Description |
|---|---|---|
| A | 85-100 | Strong performance against statutory targets and peer councils. |
| B | 70-84 | Above sector average; some improvement areas. |
| C | 55-69 | Around sector average; mixed. |
| D | 40-54 | Below sector average; specific concerns. |
| F | 0-39 | Significant failings against statutory targets or peer councils. |
Tier applicability
Not every metric applies to every council. The two-tier structure in Kent divides remit between Kent County Council (which handles education, social care, transport, minerals/waste planning) and the 12 districts/boroughs (which handle refuse collection, planning, housing, local council tax). Medway is a unitary — it does the lot. Per-council pages show "N/A — not this tier's remit" for metrics that don't apply.
| Metric | County (KCC) | Unitary (Medway) | District / borough |
|---|---|---|---|
| Refuse collection | N/A | ✓ | ✓ |
| Complaints handling | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| FOI response | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Financial health | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Transparency | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Planning | N/A* | ✓ | ✓ |
| Housing & homelessness | N/A | ✓ | ✓ |
| Education & children's services | ✓ | ✓ | N/A |
| Safeguarding & LADO | ✓ | ✓ | N/A |
| Highways | ✓ | ✓ | N/A |
| Adult social care | ✓ | ✓ | N/A |
| Manifesto delivery (Trust) | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| School-system health (separate area) | ✓ | ✓ | —** |
* KCC handles only minerals and waste planning, which is too narrow
to score on its own; the bulk of planning sits with districts.
** School-system health is shown only on the county (KCC) and
unitary (Medway) pages because that's the boundary at which the
data aggregates cleanly. Districts have no school-system view of
their own — schools in a district fall under the parent LA.
Political attribution
Council performance data lags. A score published today usually measures a period that ended months earlier — and in several Kent councils, control changed hands mid-period. Crediting or blaming the wrong administration would be both unfair and inaccurate. So every scored cell names the administration (and, where continuity makes it meaningful, the leader) in office during the data period, drawn from a maintained control history of all 14 Kent councils covering May 2021 to the present.
Where a data window straddles a change of control, the note says so explicitly and apportions the period. The clearest current example is Kent County Council, where Reform UK took control on 22 May 2025 after 28 years of Conservative administration: KCC data windows that span that date carry dual attribution — Conservative to May 2025, Reform UK from May 2025 — and budget-versus-delivery splits are noted where they matter (the 2025-26 budget was set by the outgoing Conservative administration in February 2025, while most of the year's delivery fell to Reform UK). Attribution is factual and neutral: it records who held office during the period measured, not who deserves credit or blame — readers can judge that for themselves.
Metric 1 — Refuse collection district + unitary
What it measures: reliability and quality of household waste collection services.
Components (proposed):
- Missed-bin reports per 100,000 collections (40%)
- Recycling rate vs national average (30%)
- Complaint resolution time (20%)
- Service consistency (missed-collection variance week to week) (10%)
Data sources: DEFRA WasteDataFlow returns (published quarterly), council customer-service KPI publications, KLN FOI requests where data is not publicly available.
Metric 2 — Complaints handling
What it measures: how well the council handles complaints from residents.
Components (proposed):
- LGSCO (Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman) upheld findings per 100,000 population (40%)
- Average council response time to formal complaints (30%)
- Formal-complaint volume trend (20%)
- Complaints policy publication compliance (10%)
Data sources: LGSCO annual decisions and council reports; council annual complaints reports; KLN FOI requests.
Metric 3 — FOI response
What it measures: compliance with the Freedom of Information Act 2000, which mandates a 20-working-day response.
Components:
- Timeliness (50%) — the share of FOI and EIR requests answered within the statutory 20 working days in the latest completed financial year. Scored on a fixed scale, linear between these points: 100% = 95, 95% = 85, 90% = 70, 85% = 50, 80% = 40, 75% = 30, 70% or below = 20. The Information Commissioner's Office expects at least 90%.
- Refusal/exemption rate (30%) — not currently scored for any council. The answers to KLN's standardised request showed that councils record refusals on different bases (some count "information not held" as a refusal, some record only the exemptions applied, some record nothing), so the rates are not comparable. The figures each council supplied are reported in its note, and the other two components are re-weighted pro rata.
- ICO decision-notice findings (20%) — decision notices published by the Information Commissioner in the three years before the refresh date: no notices, or none upheld = 85; upheld findings but none on timeliness = 65; one or more upheld findings of failure to respond in time = 50; lower where upheld findings are numerous (Folkestone & Hythe 45, Kent County Council 30). Decision notices are complainant-driven, so a low count is not proof of good practice.
Data sources: each council's answer to the standardised information request KLN made to all 14 councils in July and August 2026 (requests received, number answered within 20 working days, refusals, internal reviews and ICO complaints for 2023/24 to 2025/26); councils' own published FOI statistics where they exist; ICO published decision notices.
Metric 4 — Financial health & budget discipline
What it measures: how well the council manages public money — day-to-day revenue spending against budget, major capital project delivery, reserves resilience, the external auditor's value-for-money judgment, and how its council tax positioning compares to peer councils.
Components (proposed):
- Revenue budget variance (25%) — net revenue spend vs approved budget in most recent completed FY. Penalises both overspend AND large underspend (poor forecasting).
- Capital programme delivery (20%) — aggregate cost variance plus timeline slippage across the council's published capital programme (regeneration schemes, new builds, major IT projects, leisure investments).
- Reserves & Section 114 risk (20%) — usable reserves as % of net revenue expenditure, combined with LGA financial resilience index banding.
- External auditor VfM judgment (15%) — annual external auditor's value-for-money opinion: significant weaknesses identified, qualified opinion, statutory recommendations.
- Council tax positioning (10%) — Band D council tax level for this tier vs national average for the same tier (county / unitary / district averaged separately).
- Council tax trajectory (10%) — compound annual growth rate of Band D council tax over 5 years vs national CAGR for the same tier.
What this picks up: SEND and adult social care overspend cycles; capital programme slippage (regeneration delays, leisure-centre rebuilds, IT transformation projects); council tax rises above national average without matching service delivery; external auditors flagging weaknesses.
What this deliberately does NOT pick up: major national infrastructure projects (Lower Thames Crossing, HS2, etc.) — those are National Highways / DfT / Network Rail, not council schemes. Where a council's engagement with such projects is worth measuring (statutory consultation responses, mitigation negotiations, planning objections), that sits in Planning + Transparency. Pension fund performance is also excluded; the Kent Local Government Pension Scheme is held by KCC for itself and the districts and is complex enough to need its own treatment.
Data sources: council Statements of Accounts (audited, published annually), external auditor annual reports, MHCLG council tax statistics, CIPFA financial resilience analysis, LGA Financial Resilience Index, council annual capital outturn reports.
Metric 5 — Transparency
What it measures: how openly the council publishes data about itself.
Components (proposed):
- Compliance with Local Government Transparency Code 2015 mandatory publications (40%)
- Councillor expenses and allowances publication detail (15%)
- Contract register publication detail (15%)
- Committee paper publication completeness and timeliness (15%)
- Open-data portal presence and update frequency (15%)
Data sources: direct inspection of each council's website on a fixed audit date each quarter; data.gov.uk index; KLN audit script.
Metric 6 — Planning district + unitary
What it measures: the planning service's performance against statutory targets.
Components:
- Major applications decided in time (30%) — within 13 weeks or an agreed extension, over 24 months, against the England average.
- Non-major applications decided in time (30%) — within 8 weeks or an agreed extension, over 24 months, against the England average.
- Major decisions overturned at appeal (25%) — over 24 months, against the England average.
- Planning enforcement activity (15%) — formal notices issued (enforcement, breach-of-condition, stop and temporary stop notices) per 100 planning decisions in the latest 12 months, against the England rate. Planning contravention notices, which are investigative, are reported but not scored.
Scoring: each of the first three components scores 60 at the England average, 90 at the best possible result and 10 at the national designation threshold (60% of majors in time, 70% of non-majors, 10% of major decisions overturned), linear between. Enforcement scores 60 at the England rate, 30 where no formal notice was issued and 80 at one and a half times the England rate or more. The enforcement range is deliberately narrower: the figures count activity, not effectiveness, and the numbers are small. A low count can mean breaches resolved without a notice; a high count can mean a backlog. MHCLG collects no data on complaints received, compliance achieved or prosecutions.
Data sources: MHCLG planning application statistics — designation-regime tables P151, P153 and P152 and the PS1 district returns (enforcement and decisions).
Metric 7 — Education & children's services county + unitary
What it measures: the local authority's performance on the education and children's services it actually controls — not school-level outcomes (which are an Ofsted / DfE matter at the school or trust level, not the LA's). Applies to KCC and Medway only; districts/boroughs do not have this remit.
Components (proposed):
- SEND/EHCP statutory processing within 20 weeks vs national average (35%)
- SEND tribunal LA-loss rate — parent-won appeals against the LA's SEND decisions (25%)
- Children's services Ofsted ILACS judgements — sub-judgement average; see "How we score Ofsted judgements" below (25%)
- School transport delivery reliability (KCC: KSL contract performance; Medway: contracted operators) (15%)
How we score Ofsted judgements from April 2026
Until this year, Metrics 7 and 8 took their headline from Ofsted's overall effectiveness grade for a council's children's services — the single word (Outstanding, Good, Requires Improvement or Inadequate) awarded at each full ILACS inspection. From 1 April 2026, that grade no longer exists. Ofsted has removed the overall judgement from its inspections of local authority children's services and now publishes four separately graded judgements instead: the experiences and progress of children who need help and protection; of children in care; of care leavers; and the impact of leaders on social work practice. Each is still graded on the same four-point scale. Kent County Council's November 2025 inspection was the last in Kent to carry an overall grade; Medway's next inspection will be reported under the new format.
So that the scorecard stays comparable across councils and across time, we convert Ofsted's judgements to points and average them. Each of the four sub-judgements scores Outstanding = 4, Good = 3, Requires Improvement = 2, Inadequate = 1; Metric 7 takes the mean of all four. Metric 8, which focuses on safeguarding, takes the mean of the two safeguarding-relevant judgements — children who need help and protection, and the impact of leaders on practice — since these are where Ofsted assesses whether children at risk are identified and protected. For inspections carried out before April 2026 we apply exactly the same conversion to their sub-judgements rather than using the old overall grade, so old and new reports are scored on an identical basis. As a check, this method reproduces the overall grades Ofsted actually awarded at both Kent councils' most recent graded inspections (KCC: Good, November 2025; Medway: Good, July 2023).
Between full inspections, Ofsted's focused visits and monitoring visits are letters without grades. These do not change a council's M7/M8 score, but we report their findings alongside it as an indicator of direction of travel, and we say so explicitly when a score rests on an inspection that is several years old. Joint Ofsted/CQC Area SEND inspections use a different, three-category outcome scale that grades the whole local partnership (council and NHS together), so they feed the Metric 7 narrative rather than the number. As with every metric, the source reports are linked so readers can check our working.
Note: LADO and multi-agency safeguarding sit in Metric 8 — Safeguarding below. They're treated as their own metric so they don't get drowned in education numbers; the public-interest weight on safeguarding warrants standalone visibility.
What this metric deliberately does NOT include: school-level outcomes (GCSE/A-level results, Ofsted school inspection ratings, absence rates) — those sit with the school or the academy trust, not the LA. The LA's role is to plan, fund (for maintained schools), and arbitrate. We measure the LA on that, not on aggregate school performance.
Data sources: DfE annual SEND statistics, HM Courts & Tribunals SEND tribunal data, Ofsted ILACS published inspection reports, KCC/Medway children's services annual reports and audited financial statements, KLN FOI requests where data is not published.
Metric 8 — Safeguarding & LADO county + unitary
What it measures: the LA's statutory child safeguarding function — the Local Authority Designated Officer (LADO) pathway, multi-agency safeguarding hub (MASH) operations, and Section 47 child-protection enquiries. Applies to KCC and Medway only.
Components (proposed):
- LADO referral acknowledgement and investigation timeline vs Working Together to Safeguard Children 2023 statutory windows (35%)
- Multi-agency MASH timeliness — initial decision within 1 working day of referral (25%)
- Section 47 enquiry completion within 15 working days (20%)
- Independent safeguarding audit / Kent Safeguarding Children Multi-Agency Partnership (KSCMP) annual report findings (10%)
- Looked-after children (LAC) placement stability — % LAC with 3+ placements in year (lower better) (10%)
Why standalone: child safeguarding is the highest public-interest area of LA work; bundling it into "education" dilutes accountability. Reports and inspections of LADO operations and MASH are published separately; we score them separately.
Ofsted input: where this metric draws on ILACS judgements, it uses the mean of the two safeguarding-relevant sub-judgements — children who need help and protection, and the impact of leaders on practice — under the same conversion described in "How we score Ofsted judgements from April 2026" above.
Data sources: KSCMP annual reports, KCC and Medway children's services public reports, Ofsted ILACS reports (with LADO sections extracted), DfE LAC official statistics, KLN FOI requests.
School-system health separate area — county + unitary
What it measures: aggregate school-level performance across the LA's geographic area. Not a council score — schools are accountable through Ofsted and academy trusts, not the local authority. Provided because residents reasonably want to know how schools in their area are doing.
Shown on the KCC and Medway scorecard pages as a separate panel beneath the main metrics, clearly labelled and explained as measuring the school system rather than the council.
Components:
- School Ofsted ratings — the share of state-funded schools holding an overall Ofsted grade that were rated Good or Outstanding. This is a frozen legacy measure: Ofsted stopped awarding overall grades in September 2024 and its last file carrying one for every school is dated 31 August 2025. Ofsted publishes no local-authority figure, so KLN aggregates its school-level data.
- GCSE Attainment 8 — the area average against England, with the share of pupils achieving grade 5 or above in English and maths reported alongside.
- Pupil absence — the overall absence rate for the full academic year against England, with persistent absence reported alongside.
- Post-16 progression — the share of students finishing 16-18 study who went on to a sustained education, apprenticeship or employment destination, against England.
Scoring: each cell is 55 multiplied by the area figure divided by the England figure (inverted for absence, where lower is better), so an area exactly at the England average scores 55. The cells are not combined and are not a score of the council.
Data sources: official statistics only — Ofsted state-funded schools inspections and outcomes, DfE key stage 4 performance, DfE pupil absence in schools in England, and DfE 16-18 destination measures. Each cell states its dataset, period and link.
District-level school-system data is not shown separately because school admission boundaries are LA-level (KCC), not district-level; aggregating only the schools physically inside a district would give a misleading view of "schools serving that district".
Metric 9 — Manifesto delivery (Trust score) all councils
What it measures: what the controlling party (or coalition) promised at the most recent election against what was actually delivered while in office. A public-accountability score designed to make explicit what residents otherwise have to track themselves.
Pledge categorisation: each manifesto commitment we track is placed in one of five buckets:
- KEPT — substantively delivered. Council can point to verifiable evidence the commitment is in place.
- PARTIAL — some progress but falls short of the original promise. Half-counts in the score.
- BROKEN — clear failure, abandoned without justifiable cause, or replaced with something contradictory.
- PENDING — in progress, not yet judgeable. Excluded from the denominator.
- OUT_OF_SCOPE — circumstances changed beyond the council's control (LGR dissolves authority, central-government funding withdrawn, etc.). Excluded from the denominator.
Score formula — two components averaged:
PledgeRatio = (KEPT × 1.0 + PARTIAL × 0.5) / (KEPT + PARTIAL + BROKEN) IssueRatio = (ALIGNED × 1.0 + MIXED × 0.5) / (ALIGNED + MIXED + COUNTERACTING) TrustScore = ((PledgeRatio + IssueRatio) / 2) × 100
The Trust score combines TWO accountability lenses:
- Pledge delivery — did the council do what it said it would do (from the manifesto)? Tracked in the per-council pledge tracker.
- Public-issues alignment — is the council taking actions that work in residents' direction on the top issues residents actually care about? Tracked in the per-council public-issues panel.
Both lenses matter. A council can deliver every pledge while counteracting residents on the issues they actually care about most; a council can also be broadly aligned with residents on big issues while failing on specific commitments. Combining the two prevents either side from gaming the score.
Banding follows the same A-F scale as other metrics. PENDING and OUT_OF_SCOPE pledges are excluded from the pledge ratio denominator; SILENT issues are excluded from the issue ratio denominator. If only one of pledges or issues is scoreable at a given refresh, the Trust score reflects that side alone with a transparency note.
What counts as a "pledge":
- Specific, verifiable commitments from the controlling party's manifesto at the most recent council election
- Pledges with a discrete deliverable (build X, open Y, freeze Z) — not vague aspirations ("improve services")
- Commitments within the council's actual statutory remit — not central-government policy
- For minority administrations or coalitions: each coalition partner's published manifesto counts, with overlap resolved editorially
Editorial process:
- KLN editorial team curates each council's pledge list from the manifesto + election material
- Each pledge gets a permalink page documenting source, date, KLN's judgment, and supporting evidence
- Council leadership receives the preliminary pledge tracker 14 days before publication for factual correction (longer than the 7 days for data metrics because pledge-by-pledge judgment may need substantive reply)
- Council's response is published verbatim alongside each pledge where they choose to provide one
- Pledges are re-evaluated quarterly; status changes are logged
Why this metric is hard: "PARTIAL" vs "BROKEN" involves editorial judgment; coalitions mean reconciling multiple manifestos; LGR may make KCC's 2023 manifesto moot. The mitigation is transparency — every judgment is sourced, dated, and the council has right of reply on each.
Data sources: party manifestos (archived at publication), council press releases, council meeting minutes, official statistics, FOI responses, news reporting (KLN's own + cross-checked from credible sources).
Metric 10 — Housing & homelessness district + unitary
What it measures: how the housing authority is coping with homelessness and whether enough homes, and enough affordable homes, are being built. Applies to the 12 districts and Medway; Kent County Council is not a housing authority.
Components:
- Households in temporary accommodation per 1,000 households (40%) — at the latest published quarter end. Scored against the rate for England outside London (the England figure is dominated by London): that rate scores 55, zero scores 90 and four times that rate scores 10.
- Homelessness prevention (25%) — the share of prevention duties that ended with a home secured for six months or more, latest full financial year. The England rate scores 55, with one point for each percentage point above or below.
- Affordable homes completed (20%) — completions over three years as a share of the homes the Housing Delivery Test required over the same three years. There is no England benchmark for this ratio, so the Kent median scores 55, double the median 90 and zero 20.
- Housing Delivery Test (15%) — the latest measurement, banded by the consequences national planning policy attaches to it: no consequence (95% or more) 85; action plan 65; 20% buffer 45; presumption in favour of sustainable development 10 to 35, scaled by the result.
Where a council made no return for a component, that component is excluded and the others re-weighted; where a quarterly figure is missing, the latest published quarter is used and the date stated. Temporary accommodation is a stock that reflects years of placements and local rents as much as current performance, and affordable completions are lumpy and partly outside a council's control, which is why they are averaged over three years.
Data sources: MHCLG statutory homelessness statistics (detailed local authority tables), MHCLG affordable housing supply statistics (Live Table 1011), MHCLG Housing Delivery Test measurement.
Metric 11 — Highways county + unitary
What it measures: the condition of the roads the highway authority maintains and how quickly it repairs them. Applies to Kent County Council and Medway Council only.
Components:
- A-road condition (30%) — the share of A-road length where maintenance should have been considered. The England figure scores 55, zero 90 and double the England figure 20.
- B and C road condition (30%) — the same measure and scale.
- Repair time (25%) — the share of potholes repaired within the council's own published standard or, where a council publishes no pothole-specific figure, the share of all highway defects repaired within its standard. Meeting the council's own target scores 70, with two points for each percentage point above or below. The two councils' measures are not identical and the note on each says which is used.
- Highways maintenance transparency report (15%) — published by the Department for Transport's deadline in each of the last two years 85; one year 55; neither 20.
Reported but not scored: the condition of unclassified roads (there is no national survey standard, so authorities' figures are not comparable), the Department for Transport's own maintenance rating, and pothole counts (the councils count them differently).
Data sources: DfT road condition statistics (tables RDC0120 and RDC0130), DfT local road maintenance ratings, each council's highways maintenance transparency report and published performance reports.
Metric 12 — Adult social care county + unitary
What it measures: the quality of the council's adult social care as assessed by the regulator and as experienced by the people who use it. Applies to Kent County Council and Medway Council only.
Components:
- Care Quality Commission assessment (50%) — the nine quality-statement scores from the CQC's local authority assessment, as a percentage of the maximum. Scored on the CQC's own rating thresholds: 25% scores 10, 39% (the start of "requires improvement") 40, 63% (the start of "good") 70 and 88% (the start of "outstanding") 90, linear between.
- Satisfaction (25%) — overall satisfaction of people who use services and of carers, each compared with England allowing for the survey's margin of error: above England 70, no significant difference 55, below 40. The two are averaged.
- Living at home (15%) — the share of people receiving long-term support who live at home or with family, for ages 18 to 64 and 65 and over. The England figure scores 55, with two points for each percentage point above or below; the two are averaged.
- Waiting-time publication (10%) — whether the council regularly publishes how long people wait for a care needs assessment: regular publication 85; a one-off report 55; nothing 20.
Data sources: CQC local authority assessment reports, the Adult Social Care Outcomes Framework (DHSC), council committee performance reports.
Kent Council Scorecard Awards
Once a year, at the October refresh and only after that round's right of reply has closed, KLN names the highest-scoring council on each metric that applies to most councils: refuse, complaints, FOI, finances, transparency, planning and housing, plus the largest single-metric improvement over the year. There is no overall "council of the year", because the metrics are never combined. Metrics that apply to only two councils (education, safeguarding, highways, adult social care) and the Trust score, which is an editorial judgement, are reported but not awarded. Ties are shared. The bottom of each table is reported factually in the same piece.
Top public issues separate area — all councils + Kent-wide
What it shows: the top public issues residents actually face — Kent-wide and per council. Editorial assessment, not a metric score. We do not aggregate this into a number because the underlying judgement is qualitative; pretending otherwise would mislead.
Key principle: we judge on actions, not statements. A council that publicly opposes a policy while taking actions that enable it is not ALIGNED with residents on that issue — it is COUNTERACTING or MIXED, depending on the evidence. Pushback rhetoric without operational follow-through fails the alignment test. Conversely, a council can be ALIGNED on an issue it says little about, if its actions consistently track resident interest.
Each issue carries one of four alignment tags:
- 🟢 ALIGNED — council is taking actions that work in residents' direction. Statements may or may not match; what matters is the action record.
- 🟡 MIXED — some council action, falls short or sends mixed signals. Includes "statements oppose but actions go along."
- 🔴 COUNTERACTING — council actions take the opposite direction from residents, regardless of stated position.
- ⚫ SILENT — issue widely felt but neither statements nor actions reveal a clear council position.
We are explicit about COUNTERACTING because the existing "performance dashboard" genre implicitly assumes councils always want to respond to residents. In real Kent council politics, sometimes they don't — even when their rhetoric says otherwise. KLN names that.
How issues are selected:
- KLN editorial judgement based on: council complaints data + LGSCO findings + recurring KLN reader interest + public petitions + consultation response volumes + ongoing KLN investigation series.
- For Kent-wide: the top 5 issues that affect residents across multiple Kent councils.
- For each council: the top 3 issues specific to that council's residents.
- Issues are reviewed quarterly; lineup may change as new issues emerge or existing ones resolve.
Right of reply: councils may flag factual errors or provide their position on any listed issue. Position statements published verbatim. Same 14-day window as pledge tracker.
Things we deliberately do NOT measure (yet)
- Housing association and landlord performance — Metric 10 covers only the housing authority's own homelessness duties and the planning-led supply measures; the condition and management of social housing, much of it owned by housing associations, is not scored.
- Care providers — Metric 12 scores the council's own adult social care function; individual care homes and agencies are regulated and rated by the CQC.
- Single "overall" ranking — combining unrelated metrics produces misleading league tables. We don't.
- School-level outcomes as a council score — covered separately in the "School-system health" panel on the KCC and Medway pages, with explicit disclaimer that this is not a council performance score.
These may be added in future versions if a robust methodology can be defined.
Right of reply process
- Preliminary scores compiled internally each quarter.
- Each council receives an itemised notice of every new or changed score, with the basis for it, at least 14 working days before publication, by email to its press office.
- The council may flag factual errors or missing context; we publish their response verbatim alongside the score where they choose to provide one.
- If a council disputes a methodological choice (rather than a fact), we publish their position and ours.
- Scores are published with the right-of-reply window evidenced.
Change log
- 2026-05-18 — initial DRAFT published; methodology under editorial review.
- 2026-05-18 — added Metric 7 (Education & children's services, county/unitary only); added tier-applicability table; refined Refuse + Planning as district/unitary-only metrics.
- 2026-05-18 — split LADO + safeguarding out of Education into standalone Metric 8 (Safeguarding & LADO, county/unitary). Re-weighted Education to 35/25/25/15 across 4 components. Added separate "School-system health" panel (KCC + Medway only) for aggregate school-level data, explicitly framed as not a council score. Added Metric 9 (Manifesto delivery / Trust score, all councils).
- 2026-05-18 — Metric 4 (Financial health) rewritten as "Financial health & budget discipline". Added explicit components for revenue budget variance, capital programme delivery, and council tax positioning vs national average. Now 6 components; sources to council Statements of Accounts + external auditor reports + MHCLG council tax statistics.
- 2026-05-18 — Methodology PUBLISHED. Editorial sign-off complete; methodology lifted from DRAFT to operative. Data collection now in progress for first quarterly refresh.
- 2026-05-18 — Initial pledge set published for Metric 9. Detailed pledge tracking for KCC (Reform UK 2025), Medway (Labour 2023), and Tunbridge Wells (Lib Dem 2026) populated from publicly-available manifesto material + KLN's existing investigation series. Remaining 11 districts have empty pledge trackers pending subsequent curation passes. 14-day right-of-reply window opens for the populated councils; closes 2026-06-06.
- 2026-05-18 — Pledge tracking extended to all 14 Kent councils. Maidstone (Green/LD/Independent coalition May 2024), Canterbury (Lab/LD May 2023), Thanet (Lab May 2023), Ashford (Independents/Greens May 2023), Tonbridge & Malling (Cons May 2023), Sevenoaks (Cons NOC since 2023), Dartford (Cons), Dover (Lab May 2023), Folkestone & Hythe (Greens/LD May 2023), Gravesham (Lab May 2023), and Swale (Lab/Ind/Green rainbow coalition May 2023) all populated. Every council now has a curated pledge list. 14-day right-of-reply window applies to all populated trackers; closes 2026-06-06.
- 2026-05-18 — Top Public Issues area added (separate from the 9 metrics). Kent-wide top 5 panel on the scorecard hub. Per-council top 3 panels on each council page. Four alignment tags: ALIGNED / MIXED / COUNTERACTING / SILENT. Editorial assessment, not a metric score. 14-day right-of-reply window applies; closes 2026-06-06.
- 2026-05-18 — "Actions, not statements" principle codified + applied. Public-issues alignment is judged on actions taken, not statements made. Statements opposing a policy while actions enable it = COUNTERACTING (not ALIGNED). Initial pledge set re-reviewed and adjusted: LGR (Kent-wide + KCC) recategorised to COUNTERACTING on grounds councils have engaged with LGR process + restructured internally + (per KLN investigation) spent £113m+ during a period when statutory authority was absent — actions enable despite oppositional rhetoric. 15 other ALIGNED tags downgraded to MIXED where alignment was statement-based without verified action evidence. ALIGNED reserved for cases with concrete action: Maidstone Rights of Nature adoption, Ashford Carbon Plan adoption, Medway + Sevenoaks council-tax positions maintained, Gravesham leaseholder-reform campaign that contributed to Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024, Gravesham homelessness partnership funding.
- 2026-05-18 — Trust score (Metric 9) combined formula. Metric 9 now averages the pledge-delivery ratio AND the public-issues alignment ratio. A council can no longer earn a high Trust score by delivering pledges while counteracting residents on the top public issues. Worked example: KCC scores 80 on pledges alone but ~33 on public-issues alignment (one COUNTERACTING on LGR, two MIXED), producing combined Trust score ~57 (Band C). Methodologically symmetric — both lenses weighted equally; SILENT/PENDING/OUT_OF_SCOPE items excluded from their respective denominators.
- 2026-07-03 — First quarterly refresh: scores populated. Data basis: Metric 1 from DEFRA's local-authority collected waste final results 2024-25 (published 31 Mar 2026) — recycling-rate and residual-waste components for the 13 collection authorities, remaining components pending. Metric 2 from LGSCO per-council performance statistics for 2025-26 and 2024-25; the 2025-26 annual letters are not yet issued (~July 2026), so figures may be revised; districts are scored on process indicators with an explicit small-numbers caveat, never on the raw uphold percentage alone. Metric 3 scored only for KCC and Folkestone & Hythe — the only two councils publishing usable FOI performance data; the other 12 cells remain pending, with notes recording each council's ICO decision-notice count (3-year window), WhatDoTheyKnow request volume and the non-publication finding itself. Metric 4 from council outturn reports, Statements of Accounts, Grant Thornton auditor's annual reports and MHCLG council tax statistics 2026-27, across all six components (mixed 2024/25 and 2025/26 outturn years, flagged per council; pre-audit figures flagged as provisional). Metric 5 from a fixed-date website audit of all 14 councils on 2026-07-03. Metric 6 from MHCLG planning statistics (Jan–Mar 2026 edition, 24-month designation-regime windows; enforcement component pending). Throughout, missing components are named in the cell note and re-weighted pro rata — never estimated.
- 2026-07-03 — Political attribution principle adopted. Every scored cell now names the administration in office during its data period, per a compiled control history of all 14 Kent councils (May 2021 → present). Data windows straddling a change of control carry dual attribution — most notably KCC, where windows spanning 22 May 2025 are attributed Conservative (to May 2025) / Reform UK (from May 2025). New "Political attribution" section added above.
- 2026-07-03 — Ofsted sub-judgement mapping for Metrics 7–8. From 1 April 2026 Ofsted no longer awards an overall effectiveness grade for local authority children's services. Metric 7 now averages the four graded sub-judgements (Outstanding = 4, Good = 3, Requires Improvement = 2, Inadequate = 1); Metric 8 averages the two safeguarding-relevant judgements. Applied retrospectively to pre-2026 inspections so old and new reports score on an identical basis; the mapping reproduces the overall grades actually awarded at KCC (Good, Nov 2025) and Medway (Good, Jul 2023), so the framework change causes no score discontinuity. Full explanation under Metric 7.
- 2026-07-06 — Right of reply opened on the first refresh. Each of the 14 councils received an itemised notice of every new or changed score, the basis for it, and the political attribution, with a single deadline of 17:00 on Friday 24 July 2026 (14 working days). Council responses were to be published verbatim alongside the affected cell.
- 2026-09-10 — First quarterly refresh PUBLISHED. [As first published, this entry said no council had responded within the right-of-reply window or since. That was wrong — see the 2026-10-01 correction below.] Scores as itemised in the 6 July notices are now live on every council page, together with per-metric comparison tables on the hub, share cards, and cross-links between council pages and town news hubs. Late responses remain welcome and will be published verbatim. The October 2026 refresh will score Metric 3 (FOI) for all 14 councils from the standardised information request KLN sent every council in July and August 2026, and will re-check the Metric 2 figures against the LGSCO annual letters issued since July.
- 2026-09-10 — Corrections to published text. Metric 8 component 2 cited "Working Together 2018"; the statutory guidance in force is Working Together to Safeguard Children 2023 and the text now says so (no scoring effect). The Kent County Council and Kent-wide "Local Government Reorganisation" public-issue entries were re-based on KLN's published investigation record: the May wording that the Reform UK administration had made "push-back on LGR a public strategic priority" did not reflect the council's actions and has been replaced. The Medway children's-safeguarding public issue was re-based on the published Ofsted record and no longer refers to an individual case. A sweep of every other public-issue entry the same day produced: KCC pledge "push back on Government-imposed unitary structures" PARTIAL → BROKEN on the same record; Folkestone & Hythe "Princes Parade" MIXED → ALIGNED (the cancellation promised in 2023 has been carried out); Thanet housing corrected (council housing returned in-house on 1 October 2020 under the previous administration, not as a 2023 pledge; the 2023 pledge is 400 affordable homes over four years); and council-position wording updated where the administration described no longer exists — Swale (rainbow coalition dissolved December 2024, Labour minority since), Sevenoaks (Conservative minority since May 2025), Tonbridge & Malling (Conservative-led coalition, no overall control) and Maidstone (Green-led coalition, not "Lib Dem-led"). Trust scores (Metric 9) recompute automatically from these changes.
- 2026-10-01 — Correction: two councils responded to the July right of reply. The 10 September entry above, the Scorecard hub and KLN's article of 12 September said no council had responded within the right-of-reply window. That was wrong. Ashford Borough Council responded on 13 July 2026 and Kent County Council on 21 July 2026, both inside the window that closed on 24 July. Both responses reached KLN and were not taken into account before publication; the error was KLN's. Both are now published verbatim beside the cells they concern. Arising from them: Ashford, Metric 3 — the council does publish FOI performance statistics on its Information Rights page, and did so before KLN's 3 July audit, which missed them; the note saying it published none has been corrected (the score remains pending until the October refresh). Ashford, Metric 5 — the council publishes a contracts register; score corrected from 71 to 81. Kent County Council, Metric 5 — the council publishes an FOI disclosure log; score corrected from 71 to 76. Kent County Council's objections to the political attribution of its FOI performance (Metric 3) and to the basis of the council-tax comparison (Metric 4) are published with those cells and will be considered at the October refresh. The statement that only two Kent councils publish FOI performance statistics is withdrawn. A re-check of every council on 1 October found that KLN's 3 July audit had also missed FOI timeliness figures published by Thanet (quarterly Cabinet performance reports), Maidstone (annual information-governance report) and Tonbridge & Malling (a September 2025 scrutiny report), and older figures from Canterbury (a 2023/24 indicator) and Dartford (a statistics page last updated in February 2023); Swale's statistics page, which stopped at 2021/22 at the audit date, now carries 2025/26. Those six Metric 3 notes have been corrected. KLN found no published FOI performance figures for Medway, Dover, Sevenoaks or Tunbridge Wells.
- 2026-10-01 — Correction: Medway school-system panel. The GCSE attainment note on the Medway page said 29.27% of pupils achieved grade 5 or above in English and maths against 30.84% for England. Those figures came from a secondary source and were wrong. The Department for Education's figures are 44.1% against 45.4% for 2024/25 (45.3% and 45.9% for 2023/24); the note now gives them, with the Attainment 8 score updated to 2024/25 (46.1, the same as England). The cell's score is unchanged. The whole school-system panel will be re-based on official Ofsted and Department for Education statistics at the October refresh.
- 2026-10-01 — Correction: school-system panel re-based on official statistics. Further checks found other errors in the school-system panel, which had been compiled from secondary websites. The Kent County Council page said the area had 176 Outstanding schools and that 89% of secondary and 92% of primary schools were Good or Outstanding; Ofsted's data shows 59 Outstanding schools, with 86.9% of secondary and 96.6% of primary schools that hold a grade rated Good or Outstanding. The Medway page said its share of Good or Outstanding schools was below the Kent average; it is above it (96.6% against 94.8%). All eight cells on the two pages are now taken from Ofsted and Department for Education statistics, with the dataset, period and link stated in each, and the two cells that were pending (pupil absence and post-16 progression) are populated. Each cell is now scored as 55 multiplied by the area figure divided by the England figure, so the Kent Ofsted cell moves from 80 to 56 and the Medway Ofsted cell from 60 to 57; the earlier scores had no stated basis. The panel is not a score of either council.
- 2026-10-01 — Correction: Metric 5 (transparency) audit re-checked. KLN re-checked every item its 3 July audit had marked as missing, partial or unverified, and found that the audit had missed information councils publish. The most serious error concerned Tunbridge Wells: the Scorecard said its spending data was roughly 18 months out of date. That was wrong. The council publishes monthly spending files on its main website; the audit had looked only at a separate open-data portal. The Scorecard also said Maidstone was the only Kent council with no downloadable spending files; its payments search returns downloadable quarterly files. The audit also missed contracts registers (Kent County Council, Dartford, Gravesham, Tonbridge & Malling, and an out-of-date one at Tunbridge Wells), councillor allowances (Dartford, Maidstone, Tunbridge Wells), FOI disclosure logs (Dartford, Folkestone & Hythe, Tunbridge Wells) and open-data pages (Dartford, Sevenoaks), and it misdated Medway's organisation chart, which is from May 2025, not November 2020. Tonbridge & Malling's committee-papers site, unreachable on the audit date, was retested and is now scored; Canterbury's senior-pay pages, previously unverified, were confirmed; and Sevenoaks loses partial credit for an FOI disclosure log the re-check could not find. Corrected scores: Tunbridge Wells 43 to 72, Dartford 49 to 71, Maidstone 61 to 74, Tonbridge & Malling 66 to 74, Gravesham 70 to 75, Kent County Council 76 to 81, Canterbury 72 to 74, Folkestone & Hythe 72 to 74, Sevenoaks 72 to 74 and Medway 75 to 77. Each council's page carries the correction.
- 2026-10-01 — Metric 5: Thanet contracts register. Thanet's contracts-register page points to the Kent Business Portal, whose public register listed no Thanet contracts when checked on 1 October 2026. The 3 July audit had credited the register without opening it. The item is now scored as partial and Thanet's score moves from 70 to 66.
- 2026-10-01 — Metric 3 scoring basis set. Metric 3 is now scored for every council that supplied or publishes the figures, from the councils' answers to KLN's standardised information request (for Ashford, from its own published return): timeliness in 2025/26 (50%) on a fixed published scale, and Information Commissioner decision notices in the three years to 1 October 2026 (20%). The refusal-rate component (30%) is not scored for any council, because the answers showed that refusals are recorded on bases that cannot be compared; the figures supplied are reported in each council's note. Kent County Council's score moves from its published calendar-year figure (86% in 2025) to the financial-year figure it supplied (82.1% in 2025/26), so that every council is scored on the same basis. The scale and tiers are set out under Metric 3 above. Each score was put to the council concerned for right of reply before publication.
- 2026-10-01 — October refresh: scoring bases set. Metric 6 re-scored on MHCLG's edition of 24 September 2026 (24 months to June 2026) and the planning enforcement component (15%) scored for the first time, as formal notices per 100 decisions against the England rate. Metric 10 (housing and homelessness) added for the 12 districts and Medway; Metric 11 (highways) and Metric 12 (adult social care) added for Kent County Council and Medway. Metric 2 re-checked against the Ombudsman's published 2025-26 statistics, with no change. Metric 4 updated with the 2025/26 outturns for Dartford and Folkestone & Hythe, and Kent County Council's council tax comparison re-stated on the like-for-like basis the council asked for in its right-of-reply response (county charge plus the separate fire precept, against all 21 shire counties). The right-of-reply window in this methodology was corrected to the 14 working days used in practice since July 2026. An awards section sets out how the annual per-metric awards work.
- 2026-10-17 — Metric 11 re-scored on the Department for Transport’s new edition. The Department published Road conditions in England to March 2026 on 14 October 2026, after the October refresh was staged on the January 2026 edition (year to March 2025). It is the Department’s final edition on this basis. Metric 11 now uses the year to March 2026, against the England figures of 4% (A roads) and 6% (B and C roads). Kent County Council moves from 66 (C) to 54 (D) and Medway from 69 (C) to 55 (C); both changes come from road condition alone. Both councils were sent a supplementary right-of-reply notice on 17 October 2026, with the same deadline of 17:00 on 23 October 2026; neither responded.
- 2026-10-26 — Pledge review and note wording. Folkestone & Hythe: the pledge to cancel the Princes Parade development moves from PENDING to KEPT. The scheme has not gone ahead, the council says no further activity is planned, the site hoardings have been removed, the council has consulted on the future use of the land, and its 2025/26 provisional outturn wrote off about £3.2m spent on the scheme as abandoned. KLN has not found a single resolution formally cancelling it, and the pledge note says so. The council's Trust score (Metric 9) rises from 67 (C) to 84 (B). The change is in the council's favour and was not in its October right-of-reply notice; any response will be published beside the pledge. Swale: the judgement on the coalition pledge said the coalition had run the council continuously since May 2023; it broke up in December 2024. The text is corrected and the pledge stays KEPT, because the pledge was to form a cross-party administration ending Conservative control. Dartford and Tonbridge & Malling: both Metric 4 notes described the council's reserves as the strongest in Kent, on different measures; both now describe the reserves without a ranking. Scores unchanged.
- 2026-11-02 — Reorganisation facts updated. The Kent County Council reorganisation entries now record its legal challenge of 12 October 2026 and the Government's withdrawal of the Kent and Medway decision on 29 October 2026. No score or judgement changed.
- 2026-11-02 — October 2026 refresh PUBLISHED. Every council received an itemised right-of-reply notice on 2 October 2026, with a deadline of 17:00 on 23 October 2026; supplementary notices followed for Swale and Tonbridge & Malling (Metric 3) and Kent County Council and Medway (Metric 11). Canterbury City Council replied that it had no challenges or corrections. Tonbridge & Malling Borough Council asked questions about Metrics 5, 6 and 10, which KLN answered, and commented on Metrics 3 and 5; those comments are published verbatim with the cells. No other council responded within the window. Tonbridge & Malling's Metric 3 is scored on calendar 2025, the basis on which the council records its figures; its notice gave 36, and the published 37 applies the same rounding as every other council (the timeliness component is not rounded before the two components are combined). Dover's Metric 3 remains pending because its figures arrived on 23 October, after the notices went out; Folkestone & Hythe's is held at its July score while the council clarifies its figures. The first Kent Council Scorecard Awards are published on the hub.