Council scorecard

Tonbridge & Malling Borough Council

Type
borough
Population
134,000 (ONS mid-year estimate, rounded)
Political control
No overall control — Conservative + Independent Alliance coalition (since May 2023)
Next election
6 May 2027 (whole council, all 44 seats)
Council website
www.tmbc.gov.uk

Scorecard

Methodology published 2026-05-18. Pending cells reflect data collection in progress, not methodology uncertainty — they will populate as the underlying data is gathered.

Refuse collection

Missed bin reports, recycling rates, complaint resolution time

66 C

Scored on the two DEFRA-published components — recycling rate and residual household waste, FY 2024-25 final data (England averages: 42.0% / 513.3kg per household) — with the remaining components (missed-bin reports, complaint resolution time, service consistency) pending data ingest. Tonbridge & Malling recycled 48.4% of household waste in 2024-25 — third-best in Kent and well above the England average of 42.0% — though its residual waste (448.7kg per household) is heavier than its recycling rank suggests (England: 513.3kg). Attribution: Conservative + Independent Alliance coalition (Matt Boughton), in office throughout the period.

as of 2026-07-02 · source

Complaints handling

Volume, response times, LGSCO upheld findings

52 D

Small-numbers caveat: district-tier LGSCO investigation counts are tiny (0–4 a year) and a single case can swing the uphold percentage from 0% to 100%, so this score rests on process indicators — upheld volume per 100,000 residents vs the 1.0 district average, remedies offered before the Ombudsman, and compliance with recommendations — across 2025-26 and 2024-25, never on the raw uphold percentage alone. The 2025-26 figures were re-checked against the Ombudsman's published statistics on 1 October 2026 and are unchanged. 2025-26: 2 investigations, 2 upheld — 1.5 upheld per 100,000 residents vs the 1.0 district average — with no pre-Ombudsman remedy and timely compliance of 50% vs the 75% district average; 2024-25: 1 upheld of 1, compliance met. Attribution: Conservative + Independent Alliance coalition (Matt Boughton) throughout both years.

as of 2026-07-02 · source

FOI response

Share of FOI requests answered within the statutory 20 working days, and Information Commissioner decision notices

37 F

Scored on two of the three components: timeliness (50%), the share of FOI/EIR requests answered within the statutory 20 working days in 2025/26, taken from the council's answer to KLN's standardised information request or from its own published return; and Information Commissioner decision notices in the three years to 1 October 2026 (20%). The refusal-rate component (30%) is not scored for any council, because councils record refusals on different bases; the figures supplied are reported, not scored. The ICO expects at least 90% of requests to be answered in time. 2025: 72.56% of FOI requests answered within 20 working days (706 of 973), from the council’s answer to KLN’s standardised information request (FOI 26/1084, 8 October 2026). The council records these figures by calendar year, where most councils supplied financial years, so calendar 2025 is used; earlier years were 77.42% in 2023 (648 of 837) and 74.60% in 2024 (658 of 882), and in 2026 to 31 August 82.63% (509 of 616). Environmental Information Regulations requests are recorded separately (12 of 18 answered in time in 2025); counting them in gives the same score. The score uses the council’s own totals for all the requests it received; how the council handled KLN’s own request plays no part in it. The council does not hold refusal figures. ICO: three decision notices in the three years to 1 October 2026. In one (IC-345906, June 2025) the Commissioner found the request had been handled under the correct regime, the Environmental Information Regulations, but that not all the relevant recorded information had been provided until later, a breach of regulation 5(1); no further steps were required. The other two (2026) were not upheld. The council’s view of that decision is published below. Attribution: Conservative + Independent Alliance coalition (Matt Boughton) throughout.

as of 2026-10-08

Tonbridge & Malling response

I appreciate the challenges involved in comparing performance across different reporting periods. However, if the Council’s FOI compliance rate of 72.56% is being taken from the 2025 calendar year, it would seem more appropriate to use the same period when considering ICO complaints to ensure a consistent and balanced assessment. On that basis, the figure would be two ICO complaints rather than three over the preceding three years. I note, however, that the 2026 compliance figure is being reported up to 31 August. I would also question the inclusion of the comment regarding “timeliness (50%) from the Council’s FOI 26/1084 return”. My understanding is that this relates to the difficulties experienced in corresponding with receiving your FOI request and your email address, which you have previously advised is not unique to ourselves. In those circumstances, I do not believe it is reasonable to use the handling of a single request, out of the Council’s overall FOI caseload of 629 to 31 August, as an indicator of the Council’s wider commitment to transparency or its overall responsiveness to FOI requests. In relation to ICO complaint IC-345906-T9R0 (June 2025), concerning an EIR request, the Commissioner concluded that the Council had correctly handled the request under the EIR. While the decision noted that additional recorded information should have been provided at an earlier stage, the Commissioner also determined, on the balance of probabilities, that the Council did not hold any further information beyond that subsequently supplied to the complainant. Importantly, the decision notice concluded that, as the complainant had since been provided with the relevant information, no further steps were required by the Council. Given those findings, I do not consider this case to represent a substantive finding against the Council. Rather, the Commissioner confirmed that the request had been handled under the correct legislative framework and did not require any remedial action beyond the information that had already been provided. (Adrian Futers, Information Governance Manager. KLN replied that the 50% is the weight of the timeliness component, not a result; that the score uses the council’s own figure of 706 of 973 and the handling of KLN’s request plays no part in it; and that the three-year ICO window is the same for all 14 councils.)

— received 2026-10-08

Financial health & budget discipline

Revenue budget variance, capital programme delivery, reserves + Section 114 risk, external auditor VfM judgment, council tax positioning + trajectory vs national

68 C

Weighted across the six published components: revenue budget variance 25%, capital programme delivery 20%, reserves & Section 114 risk 20%, external auditor VfM judgement 15%, council tax positioning 10%, council tax trajectory 10%. 2024/25 outturn: £119k (0.7%) revenue underspend, with £1.1m contributed to the general revenue reserve; a strong and growing reserves position — usable reserves £39.9m ≈ 234% of net revenue spend, up £6.2m in the year; auditor: no significant weaknesses on any criterion (all Amber), with the prior-year procurement significant weakness resolved and accounts certified. Capital delivery is the weak component: £2.9m spent against an original £6.9m programme (58% under, on a small programme, with major projects delayed into 2025/26). Council tax: Band D £252.65, 6th-highest of the 12 Kent districts; 5-yr CAGR 2.85% vs 2.64% nationally, with the 2026-27 rise at the cap. Attribution: Conservative + Independent Alliance coalition (Matt Boughton) throughout.

as of 2026-07-03 · source

Transparency

Open data publication, councillor expenses, contract register, committee paper publication

74 B

Fixed-date website audit (2026-07-03) against the Transparency Code checklist: spending-data currency and format, contracts register, councillor allowances, interests, committee papers, senior pay, open data, FOI disclosure log. Items not individually verified this quarter are scored neutrally and flagged. Monthly spending CSVs current to March 2026 (series from December 2020), a register of current contracts, councillor allowances, senior salaries, annual pay-policy statement and organisation chart all published on the transparency hub, and live committee papers. There is no FOI disclosure log or open-data portal. Updated after a re-check on 1 October 2026: the committee-papers site, which could not be reached on the audit date and had been left out of the score pending a retest, was reachable with 2026 agendas, reports and minutes, and is now scored. This note also previously said the contracts register was not verified; the register page was online before the audit date and KLN missed it. The score moves from 66 to 74. Attribution: audit conducted under the Conservative + Independent Alliance coalition (Matt Boughton).

as of 2026-07-03 · source

Tonbridge & Malling response

For Metric 5, we have now brought together the key transparency and access to information links on the Transparency page (https://www.tmbc.gov.uk/transparency-tonbridge-malling-borough-council), accessible from the ‘About the council’ page (https://www.tmbc.gov.uk/council). This provides a single location where users can find the information about accessing council-held information. The page includes links to: the Freedom of Information (FOI) request process; the Council’s Publication Scheme; transparency data publications; spending and procurement information; senior officer salaries and organisational information; councillor allowances; data protection and privacy information; other statutory transparency information including homelessness and planning enforcement data. In addition, we have identified an opportunity to improve navigation further by adding a direct ‘Request Information from the council’ and ‘Transparency data’ links within the Services menu accessible from every page on the website. We are also exploring the introduction of an FOI disclosure log, with the aim of making previously released information available proactively and improving transparency. (Diane Talbot, Head of Communications. KLN replied that the Transparency page brings together items the audit had already found and credited, so the score is unchanged; the one item not found is an FOI disclosure log.)

— received 2026-10-16

Planning

Speed of decisions on major and non-major applications, appeal-overturn rate, and enforcement activity

52 D

Scored against the England averages: speed over the 24 months to June 2026 (majors decided in time 91.0%, non-majors 90.7%), appeal quality over the 24 months to September 2025 (3.2% of major decisions overturned), and planning enforcement activity in the year to June 2026 (formal notices issued per 100 planning decisions; England 1.89). Weights 30/30/25/15. From MHCLG planning statistics published 24 September 2026. Enforcement counts measure activity, not effectiveness, and the numbers are small. The national "in time" measure includes agreed extensions of time. 93.8% of major applications (48 decisions) and 86.2% of non-majors decided in time over the 24 months to June 2026, with 6.7% of major decisions overturned at appeal over the 24 months to September 2025 (England 3.2%). Enforcement: 13 formal notices (enforcement, breach-of-condition and stop notices) against 891 planning decisions in the year to June 2026, 1.46 per 100 decisions against 1.89 for England (1 notices the year before); it also served 17 planning contravention notices, which are investigative and are not scored. Attribution: Conservative + Independent Alliance coalition (Matt Boughton) throughout the July 2024 – June 2026 window.

as of 2026-09-24 · source

Housing & homelessness

Households in temporary accommodation, homelessness prevention, affordable homes completed, Housing Delivery Test (district + unitary only)

57 C

Scored on four components: households in temporary accommodation per 1,000 households, against the rate for England outside London (40%); the share of homelessness prevention duties that ended with a home secured for six months or more in 2024-25, against the England rate (25%); affordable homes completed in the three years to March 2025 as a share of the homes the Housing Delivery Test required, against the Kent median (20%); and the Housing Delivery Test 2025 result (15%). Sources: MHCLG statutory homelessness tables, affordable housing supply Live Table 1011 and the Housing Delivery Test 2025 measurement. Temporary accommodation: 98 households at 31 March 2026, 1.74 per 1,000 households (England outside London 2.83; England 5.50), with 131 children among them. Prevention: 53.4% of homelessness prevention duties that ended in 2024-25 ended with a home secured for six months or more (175 of 328; England 51.9%); the January to March 2026 quarter was 80.6%. Across the four quarters of 2025-26, which MHCLG has published as provisional quarterly figures, 69.4% ended with a home secured (163 of 235; England 54.0%); this component is scored on the 2024-25 full-year table, the latest published on the same basis for every council, and will be re-scored when the 2025-26 full-year table is published (scheduled for 26 November 2026). Affordable homes: 457 completed in the three years to March 2025 (30, 156 and 271), 18.4% of the 2,485 homes the Housing Delivery Test required (Kent median 17.2%). Housing Delivery Test 2025: 63% of required homes delivered over 2022-23 to 2024-25, below 75%, so the presumption in favour of sustainable development applies to its planning decisions. Attribution: Conservative-led throughout: Conservative majority to May 2023, Conservative + Independent Alliance coalition (Matt Boughton) since.

as of 2026-08-13 · source

Education & children's services

SEND/EHCP statutory processing, SEND tribunal LA-loss rate, children's services Ofsted rating, school transport delivery (county + unitary only)

N/A

Education and children's services are not a district/borough function. The county council (or, for Medway, the unitary authority) holds this remit.

Safeguarding & LADO

LADO referral handling, multi-agency safeguarding (MASH) timeliness, Section 47 enquiry compliance, independent safeguarding audit findings (county + unitary only)

N/A

Safeguarding is the statutory function of the county council or unitary authority via the LADO (Local Authority Designated Officer) and multi-agency safeguarding hub.

Highways

Condition of A, B and C roads, pothole repair times against the council's own standard, publication of the highways maintenance report (county + unitary only)

N/A

Road maintenance is not a district/borough function. Kent County Council (or, for Medway, the unitary authority) is the highway authority.

Adult social care

Care Quality Commission assessment, satisfaction of people who use services and of carers, support to live at home, publication of waiting times (county + unitary only)

N/A

Adult social care is not a district/borough function. The county council (or, for Medway, the unitary authority) holds this remit.

Manifesto delivery (Trust)

KLN tracks what the controlling party promised at the most recent election vs what was actually delivered. KEPT/PARTIAL/BROKEN/PENDING/OUT_OF_SCOPE categorisation.

50 D

Trust score: 3 categorised public issues (no scoreable pledges yet).

as of 2026-11-21

Top public issues for Tonbridge & Malling residents

This is editorial assessment, not a metric score. Each issue carries an alignment tag — ALIGNED (council in step with residents), MIXED (some action falls short), COUNTERACTING (council against residents on this), or SILENT (no clear position). KLN-curated. Council positions added verbatim where provided. Right-of-reply opens with initial publication.

  1. 🟡Mixed

    Greenbelt protection + development pressure

    Tonbridge & Malling faces sustained housing-targets pressure on greenbelt sites; residents express concern about cumulative loss of green space.

    Council position

    The Conservative-led coalition with the Independent Alliance (no overall control since May 2023) is broadly resistant to large greenbelt releases outside the Local Plan; case-by-case planning decisions.

    KLN assessment

    Statements supportive; greenbelt-release approval rates + Planning Inspectorate appeal outcomes are the action evidence and not yet reviewed under Metric 6. Per the "actions, not statements" principle: MIXED.

  2. 🟡Mixed

    Recycling rates + waste services

    Residents expect strong recycling performance + reliable waste services. T&M has historically claimed strong delivery here.

    Council position

    Conservatives 2023 election material claimed strong recycling rates + tough environmental enforcement.

    KLN assessment

    Claim of strong delivery is a statement; action evidence sits in DEFRA WasteDataFlow returns + enforcement notice volumes, to be reviewed under Metric 1. Per the "actions, not statements" principle: MIXED.

  3. 🟡Mixed

    Council tax + value for money

    T&M residents expect competitive council tax position vs other Kent districts.

    Council position

    Conservatives 2023 election material claimed "best value for money" in Kent.

    KLN assessment

    Claim of best VfM is a statement; verification is Band D council tax positioning + external auditor VfM judgement under Metric 4. Per the "actions, not statements" principle: MIXED.

News from this council's area

How this scorecard works

Each metric is scored 0-100 and banded A through F. We do NOT aggregate to a single overall ranking — combining unrelated performance areas would mislead. See the methodology page for full details, thresholds, and data sources.

Spot an error or have data we should add for Tonbridge & Malling? editor@kentlocalnews.co.uk.